Back to Insights
Case Insight

The Five Court of Justice Decisions Airlines Hope You Have Never Heard Of

Airlines routinely reject EU261 claims using positions that Court of Justice case law has already overturned. These five decisions are the ones they're counting on you never to have heard of.

The Five Court of Justice Decisions Airlines Hope You Have Never Heard Of

EU261 is interpreted through Court of Justice case law that has substantially expanded passenger rights over the past two decades. Airlines routinely take positions in response to compensation claims that contradict settled case law, relying on the fact that most passengers have never heard of the specific decisions that would resolve the dispute in their favor. Understanding the five most consequential of these decisions closes much of the knowledge gap between airlines and the passengers they are negotiating with.

The gap that defines most compensation disputes

EU261 is a short regulation. The core text runs to a few pages, and the plain reading of key provisions often appears to favor airlines in common dispute scenarios. Delays. Technical issues. Cancellation notifications. Weather. Each category looks, on the regulatory text alone, like it provides substantial airline flexibility to resist claims.

The actual interpretation of these provisions has been developed by the Court of Justice of the European Union through two decades of case law. The case law interpretations are often substantially more favorable to passengers than the regulatory text alone suggests. Technical issues that look like they should defeat claims under the text do not do so under the case law. Delay thresholds that appear limited under the text apply more broadly under the case law. Notification obligations that look manageable under the text impose real burden under the case law.

Airlines are expected to apply the regulation as interpreted by the case law. In their initial responses to claims, they frequently do not. The gap between the regulation as the airline applies it and the regulation as the Court of Justice has actually interpreted it is where most abandoned claims live. Passengers who do not know the case law accept initial rejections that would be reversed on specific challenge. Passengers who do know the case law, or who engage representation that does, recover claims that would otherwise have been lost.

This article walks through the five decisions that most frequently matter in current claim disputes. Each has specific facts, a specific holding, a specific pattern of airline misapplication, and a specific implication for passengers encountering the same scenarios.

Wallentin-Hermann v Alitalia (C-549/07, 2008)

The facts. A passenger booked a flight that was cancelled due to a technical defect discovered in pre-flight inspection. The airline argued that the technical issue qualified as extraordinary circumstances and that no compensation was owed. The passenger challenged this characterization, arguing that routine technical issues are inherent to normal airline operations and do not qualify as circumstances outside the carrier’s control.

The ruling. The Court held that technical problems coming to light during routine maintenance, or caused by failure to properly maintain aircraft, do not qualify as extraordinary circumstances. The Court established the specific test: for a technical issue to qualify as extraordinary circumstances, the issue must stem from events which, by their nature or origin, are not inherent in the normal exercise of the activity of the air carrier and are beyond its actual control. Routine maintenance issues, routine component failures, and routine mechanical problems fail this test.

The Court also established that the burden is on the airline to prove the technical issue meets the test. Mere assertion is not sufficient. The airline must demonstrate the specific nature of the problem and why it falls outside the inherent risks of operating aircraft.

How airlines misapply this. The Wallentin-Hermann test is widely ignored in airline initial responses. Carriers routinely cite “technical issue,” “mechanical fault,” “unexpected technical defect,” or similar language to defeat claims without producing any evidence that the specific issue meets the Court’s test. The language sounds authoritative but it does not satisfy the legal standard.

The pattern is particularly common for issues like last-minute component replacements, items identified during pre-flight checks, warning lights requiring investigation, and failures of parts that have known service life limits. All of these are typically within the normal exercise of airline operations and routinely fail the extraordinary circumstances test when properly scrutinized.

The practical implication. For passengers receiving rejections citing technical issues without specific evidence, the appropriate response is to request the airline’s proof that the issue meets the Wallentin-Hermann test. Most airlines cannot produce this proof because the issue was routine. The initial rejection often does not survive the challenge, and payment follows.

See: Extraordinary Circumstances: What Actually Qualifies and What Airlines Pretend Qualifies

Sturgeon v Condor and Böck v Air France (C-402/07 and C-432/07, 2009)

The facts. Several passengers whose flights arrived at the final destination more than three hours late argued they were entitled to compensation equivalent to that for cancellations. The airlines took the position that the regulation only provided compensation for cancellations and denied boarding, not for delays regardless of length. The passengers argued that the practical consequences of a long delay were equivalent to a cancellation and that denying compensation for delays while providing it for cancellations produced unjustifiable differential treatment.

The ruling. The Court held that passengers whose flights arrive at the final destination three hours or more after the scheduled arrival time are entitled to compensation on the same basis as cancellation passengers. The reasoning was that the practical loss suffered by passengers with long delays is substantively equivalent to the loss suffered by cancellation passengers, and that the regulation must be interpreted to produce consistent treatment of equivalent loss.

This holding fundamentally restructured the compensation landscape. Before Sturgeon, airlines routinely treated delays as outside the compensation framework regardless of length. After Sturgeon, any delay producing arrival more than three hours late at the final destination triggers compensation under the same tier structure as cancellations.

How airlines misapply this. Fifteen years after Sturgeon, some airlines still take positions inconsistent with its holding. Common patterns include measuring delay from gate departure rather than from arrival at final destination, treating the delay as “not a cancellation” without acknowledging that Sturgeon aligned delay compensation with cancellation compensation, framing the delay as having been under three hours when the actual arrival time was later, and citing Article 6 (which addresses delays specifically) in ways that imply compensation only applies at longer delay thresholds.

The three-hour threshold applies to arrival time at the final destination, not to departure delay. A flight that departs on time but arrives three hours late due to in-flight issues qualifies. A flight that departs late but makes up time to arrive within three hours of schedule does not qualify.

The practical implication. For passengers whose flights arrived at the final destination more than three hours late, the Sturgeon holding provides a clear basis for compensation regardless of what the airline characterizes the disruption as. The specific documentation that matters is the actual arrival time compared to the scheduled arrival time. Rejections framed around departure delay, flight length, or the characterization of the event as “delay rather than cancellation” are generally inconsistent with Sturgeon and often reverse on challenge.

Krijgsman v Surinaamse Luchtvaart Maatschappij (C-302/16, 2017)

The facts. A passenger booked a flight through a travel agent. The airline cancelled the flight more than two weeks before departure and notified the travel agent. The travel agent failed to forward the notification to the passenger, who did not learn of the cancellation until well within the 14-day window. The airline argued that notification to the travel agent satisfied its obligation under Article 5(1)(c). The passenger argued that the regulation required actual passenger notification, not merely notification to an intermediary.

The ruling. The Court held that the operating carrier bears the burden of proving the passenger actually received timely notification of the cancellation. Notification to a third party does not discharge this obligation unless the airline can prove the information reached the passenger within the required timeframe. The airline retains any recourse it may have against the intermediary under their commercial relationship, but this is separate from the compensation obligation to the passenger.

The reasoning rested on the consumer protection purpose of the regulation. The entitlement runs to the passenger. The notification obligation exists to allow the passenger to make alternative arrangements. Allowing the airline to escape liability by notifying an intermediary who failed to forward would shift the risk of intermediary failure from the party that chose the intermediary relationship to the party who had no control over it.

How airlines misapply this. In current practice, Krijgsman is most frequently relevant to OTA bookings. When a passenger books through an OTA and the airline cancels, the notification goes to the OTA. If the OTA fails to forward promptly, the passenger does not receive the notification within the 14-day window.

Airlines routinely take the position that notifying the OTA was sufficient. This position is incorrect under Krijgsman but is widely used in initial rejections. Passengers who booked through OTAs and received late notification often accept these rejections without realizing the case law supports them.

The practical implication. For passengers who received cancellation notification less than 14 days before departure through an OTA or other intermediary, Krijgsman supports a claim position substantially stronger than the airline’s initial response suggests. The airline bears the burden of proving the passenger received timely notification. Delivery to an OTA that delayed forwarding does not meet this burden. Specific reference to Krijgsman in response to an airline rejection often produces reversal.

See: The 14-Day Cancellation Rule Most Passengers Never Learn

Pešková v Travel Service (C-315/15, 2017)

The facts. A flight was delayed because of a collision between the aircraft and a bird during a previous flight segment, which required additional inspections before the aircraft could operate the passenger’s flight. The airline argued the bird strike qualified as extraordinary circumstances and no compensation was owed. The passenger argued that even if the bird strike itself was extraordinary, the airline had not demonstrated it took all reasonable measures to minimize the resulting delay.

The ruling. The Court held that bird strikes are extraordinary circumstances within the meaning of EU261. However, the Court also held that the extraordinary circumstances defense requires the airline to prove not only that the circumstances occurred but also that it took all reasonable measures to avoid the delay. The Court emphasized that extraordinary circumstances alone are not sufficient to escape compensation obligation. The reasonable measures test applies in addition to and separately from the extraordinary circumstances test.

The Court also held that the time required for additional safety inspections after a bird strike must be assessed against what reasonable precautionary measures required. If the airline could have arranged inspections more quickly, used alternative aircraft, or otherwise mitigated the delay, these reasonable measures must be demonstrated for the extraordinary circumstances defense to succeed.

How airlines misapply this. Bird strikes are among the most frequently cited extraordinary circumstances defenses, and airlines routinely treat them as automatic defenses that defeat claims without further analysis. The Pešková requirement that reasonable measures be separately demonstrated is widely ignored. Airlines cite the bird strike, assert extraordinary circumstances, and reject the claim without producing evidence of what reasonable measures were taken to minimize the resulting delay.

The pattern extends beyond bird strikes to other extraordinary circumstances defenses. Weather events, air traffic control restrictions, security incidents, and strikes all require the reasonable measures showing in addition to the extraordinary circumstances showing. Airlines often cite the triggering event alone without addressing reasonable measures, and claims are rejected on an incomplete basis.

The practical implication. For claims rejected on extraordinary circumstances grounds, passengers should separately challenge the reasonable measures showing. The airline must prove both that extraordinary circumstances occurred and that it took all reasonable measures to minimize the resulting disruption. Most initial airline responses fail to address the second prong, which creates a specific basis for challenge regardless of whether the extraordinary circumstances itself is defensible.

See: The Reasonable Measures Test: The Second Half of the Extraordinary Circumstances Defense

Finnair v Lassooy (C-22/11, 2012)

The facts. A passenger was denied boarding on a flight because the airline had reorganized its operations following a strike. The airline argued the denied boarding was caused by extraordinary circumstances (the strike) and that no compensation was owed. The passenger argued that denied boarding compensation under Article 4 applies regardless of the airline’s reason for the denial.

The ruling. The Court held that the extraordinary circumstances defense does not apply to denied boarding under Article 4. The compensation obligation for denied boarding is absolute: if the airline denies boarding to a passenger with a confirmed reservation who presented on time, compensation is owed regardless of the airline’s reason. The extraordinary circumstances defense is available only for cancellations and long delays, not for denied boarding.

The reasoning: Article 4 establishes specific procedures for denied boarding (voluntary disembarkation offers before involuntary denial) and specific compensation obligations when denial occurs. The regulation does not provide for an extraordinary circumstances exception to the denied boarding compensation, and reading one into the regulation would contradict its structure.

How airlines misapply this. Airlines regularly treat denied boarding as subject to the same extraordinary circumstances framework as cancellations and delays. When operational disruptions, strikes, or capacity reductions cause the airline to deny boarding to passengers with confirmed reservations, carriers often respond that extraordinary circumstances apply and no compensation is owed. This position is directly contrary to Finnair.

The pattern is particularly common after strike disruptions, where airlines operating reduced schedules deny boarding to passengers whose booked flights were operating but had been reorganized. The airline treats this as strike-related and claims extraordinary circumstances. Finnair establishes that denied boarding compensation applies regardless of the operational cause.

The practical implication. For passengers denied boarding on flights with confirmed reservations where they presented on time, the extraordinary circumstances defense is not available to the airline regardless of what caused the denial. Rejections citing strikes, operational disruptions, or similar causes as basis for refusing denied boarding compensation are inconsistent with Finnair and generally reverse on challenge.

The denied boarding compensation amounts match the cancellation and long delay tiers: 250 euros, 400 euros, or 600 euros depending on flight distance.

See: When Airlines Rotate Defenses on Denied Boarding Claims: The Wizz Air Case

The pattern across all five decisions

A common structure runs through these decisions and the airline responses they are routinely used to challenge.

The regulation on its face appears to leave the airline substantial defensive flexibility. Technical issues sound like they should defeat claims. The 14-day notification threshold sounds like it should be easy to meet. Extraordinary circumstances sound like they should be automatic defenses. Denied boarding sounds like it should be subject to the same exceptions as other disruptions.

The case law has narrowed these defenses substantially. Wallentin-Hermann narrowed technical defenses. Sturgeon expanded compensation to long delays. Krijgsman tightened the notification burden. Pešková added the reasonable measures requirement to extraordinary circumstances defenses. Finnair eliminated the extraordinary circumstances defense for denied boarding entirely.

Airlines routinely respond to claims as if the case law did not exist. Initial rejection letters frequently invoke the pre-case-law reading of the regulation. The pattern is not accidental. It is a defensive strategy that works against passengers who do not know the case law.

Passengers who understand the case law recover claims that passengers who do not understand it abandon. This is the specific knowledge gap that services with specialized expertise bridge. The decisions are public, available, and clear. The gap is in knowing to apply them.

What this means for passengers

For passengers encountering compensation disputes, several principles follow from the pattern.

Initial airline responses are not final positions. When an airline rejects a claim, the rejection reflects the airline’s opening negotiating position, not necessarily the correct legal position. The case law is often more favorable to the passenger than the rejection suggests.

Specific case law reference changes airline positions. Rejection letters invoking generic language (“technical issue,” “extraordinary circumstances,” “notification was sent”) often reverse when challenged with specific case law citations. The airline knows the case law. The initial response is designed to work on passengers who do not.

Specialized representation produces outcomes individuals cannot easily match. The case law is detailed, developed over many decisions, and requires continuous attention to new rulings and emerging interpretive questions. Services whose practice involves these cases every day have an expertise advantage over passengers pursuing single claims that is difficult to close through self-study.

The case law continues to develop. The Court of Justice has produced additional decisions beyond these five, and new decisions issue regularly. The current state of the case law is more favorable to passengers than it was ten years ago. Airlines sometimes rely on older interpretive positions that have been superseded by subsequent rulings.

Bigger picture

The relationship between EU261 as written and EU261 as interpreted by the Court of Justice is one of the defining features of the compensation landscape. The regulation created the entitlements. The case law has shaped what those entitlements actually mean in practice. The gap between the two is where most compensation disputes are won and lost.

Airlines operate with full knowledge of the case law. Their legal departments monitor new decisions, update internal guidance, and adjust defensive strategies as the law develops. Their initial responses to passenger claims often do not reflect this knowledge, because the initial response is designed to resolve claims cheaply by relying on passenger lack of expertise rather than by stating the airline’s actual legal position.

For passengers, closing the knowledge gap is one of the highest-value things that can be done before engaging in a compensation dispute. The five decisions above are not an exhaustive list, but they cover the categories where airline responses most frequently diverge from the actual legal position. Passengers aware of these decisions have a materially different negotiating position than passengers who are not.

The compensation framework was designed to be a workable consumer protection system. The practical functioning depends on passengers knowing enough about their rights to challenge airline positions that contradict the case law. For those who do, the system often works as designed. For those who do not, the system often works against them.

See: What Claim Catalyst Actually Does For You

Frequently asked questions

Why do airlines reject claims using positions that case law has already rejected?

Because most passengers do not know the case law. Initial airline rejections are opening negotiating positions designed to resolve claims cheaply by relying on passenger lack of expertise. Airlines know the actual legal position. The gap between the rejection and the legal position is the specific tactic that produces abandoned claims from passengers who accept initial responses at face value.

Does Court of Justice case law actually bind airlines?

Yes. EU261 as applied by national courts and enforcement bodies incorporates Court of Justice interpretations. An airline position contradicting settled Court of Justice case law would not survive proper regulatory or court challenge. The practical issue is that most claims never reach regulatory or court challenge because passengers accept rejection letters that contradict the case law.

How do I know if the case law applies to my specific claim?

Each decision has specific facts and a specific holding. Applying them to a new claim requires evaluating whether the facts match the pattern the case addressed. For passengers without specialized knowledge, this is where representation produces materially better outcomes. Services familiar with the case law can evaluate quickly which decisions apply to a specific situation.

Can I cite case law directly in my response to an airline rejection?

Yes. References to specific Court of Justice decisions by case name and reference number in response to airline rejections often change the airline’s position. The case law is public and the airline is on notice of it. Specific citation forces the airline to engage with the actual legal position rather than relying on the generic rejection language.

Why do airlines continue using positions that case law has rejected?

Because the strategy works at scale. Most passengers accept initial rejections. The small subset who challenge with proper reference to case law recover their claims, but this is a minority of total claims filed. The economics of generic rejections favor the airline even when the legal position cannot survive challenge, because most passengers do not challenge.

Are there other Court of Justice decisions beyond these five that matter?

Yes. The five above are among the most frequently relevant in current disputes, but the Court has produced many additional decisions on specific issues: Rehder on jurisdiction, Nelson on duty of care, Folkerts on connecting flight delays, McDonagh on duty of care during extraordinary circumstances, and others. The case law continues to develop and specialized practice requires continuous attention to new rulings.



If your compensation claim was rejected on grounds that may contradict Court of Justice case law, Claim Catalyst evaluates each rejection against the current legal position rather than accepting the airline’s initial framing. Start a claim or learn more about how case law shapes what EU261 actually requires.

Ready to Claim Your Compensation?

Start your claim now and get your money back. No upfront fees, no risk.

Zero upfront fees
Case-by-case eligibility review

Takes less than 2 minutes. No payment required